The High Cost of High Mileage

Jan. 14, 2009
SCR emissions aftertreatment on 2010 trucks may cost more than you think
The other day I attended a presentation by Jim Hebe, the Senior Vice President of North American Sales for Navistar, Inc., about International Truck's decision to buck the industry trend and avoid using a Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) aftertreatment system in its 2010 heavy-duty diesel engines. New diesel emissions standards from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for 2010 have pushed most diesel engine manufacturers to adopt SCR systems for their new engines, so International's stand is bold and somewhat risky. Hebe knew that, and to his credit, he didn't shy away from it. What surprised me the most about his presentation was that he directly confronted the now-famous SCR benefit of improved fuel economy. Hebe said that the added cost of urea, or Diesel Emission Fluid (DEF), the essential ingredient of an SCR system, would wipe out any savings from increased fuel economy. Fleets running 2010 trucks with SCR would save 1.2 cents per mile in reduced fuel consumtion, he said, but using DEF would add three cents per mile in operating costs. "The initial cost," Hebe said, "never goes away." At this point it's hard to know what to believe. In the last go-around of diesel emissions standards, Caterpillar famously went its own way, and today that company is out of the on-highway diesel business for good. Now International is charting its own contrary course; will it suffer the same fate as Caterpillar?

About the Author

Mark O'Connell | Fleet Maintenance contributor

Sponsored Recommendations

Ask the Experts: Boost Profitability by Capturing Body Repair Materials Billables

Quality body repairs on medium- and heavy-duty trucks depend on the use of specialized adhesives, sealers, and other allied materials. Unfortunately, many shops face challenges...

Fleet Maintenance E-Book

Streamline your fleet's maintenance and improve operations with the Guide for Managing Maintenance. Learn proven strategies to reduce downtime, optimize in-house and third-party...

Celebrating Your Drivers Can Prove to be Rewarding For Your Business

Learn how to jumpstart your driver retention efforts by celebrating your drivers with a thoughtful, uniform-led benefits program by Red Kap®. Uniforms that offer greater comfort...

Guide To Boosting Technician Efficiency

Learn about the bottom line and team building benefits of increasing the efficiency of your technicians in your repair shop.